1. Which of the following best explains why the factor $r$ appears in the volume element for cylindrical coordinates?
- A.It corrects for the curvature of the $z$-axis
- B.Arcs at larger radii subtend a greater physical length for the same angle $d\theta$, so the volume element grows with $r$
- C.It is an arbitrary convention with no geometric meaning
- D.It accounts for the change in the height of the solid as $r$ increases
View Answer
Answer: Arcs at larger radii subtend a greater physical length for the same angle $d\theta$, so the volume element grows with $r$
Geometric interpretation: In cylindrical coordinates, a small change $d\theta$ in angle corresponds to an arc length of $r\, d\theta$ at distance $r$ from the $z$-axis. Hence the cross-sectional area element is $r\, dr\, d\theta$. Why the correct answer works: The factor $r$ accounts for the fact that the physical width of an angular strip increases linearly with the distance from the axis, making the volume element $r\, dr\, d\theta\, dz$. Why distractors fail: Option A is nonsensical—the $z$-axis is straight. Option C dismisses the geometric meaning. Option D incorrectly attributes $r$ to height changes, but $dz$ already handles the height.