1. In a pumping problem, a cylindrical tank of radius $r$ and height $h$ is filled with water (density $\rho$). The tank sits on the ground and water is pumped over the top rim. If $y$ measures the height from the bottom, what is the distance each thin slice at height $y$ must be lifted?
- A.$y$
- B.$h - y$
- C.$h + y$
- D.$h$
View Answer
Answer: $h - y$
Set up the coordinate system: With $y$ measured from the bottom of the tank, the top rim is at $y = h$. Determine the lifting distance: A slice at height $y$ must be raised to height $h$, so the distance is $h - y$. Why distractors fail: Option A ($y$) gives the distance from the bottom, not the distance remaining to the top. Option C ($h + y$) would mean the slice goes above the tank by $y$. Option D ($h$) treats every slice as if it starts at the very bottom.