1. Two students integrate $\int (2\sin x + \sec^2 x)\,dx$. Student A gets $-2\cos x + \tan x + 7$ and Student B gets $-2\cos x + \tan x - 3$. Which statement is correct?
- A.Only Student A is correct because $C$ must be positive
- B.Only Student B is correct because $C$ must be negative
- C.Both are correct because they differ only by a constant, and both are valid antiderivatives of the integrand
- D.Neither is correct because they did not write $+C$
View Answer
Answer: Both are correct because they differ only by a constant, and both are valid antiderivatives of the integrand
Verify the antiderivative structure: Both answers have the form $-2\cos x + \tan x + C$. Student A chose $C = 7$ and Student B chose $C = -3$. Why the correct answer works: Any two antiderivatives of the same function differ by a constant. Since both expressions differentiate back to $2\sin x + \sec^2 x$, both are correct antiderivatives. Why distractors fail: Options A and B incorrectly restrict the sign of $C$. Option D incorrectly insists on the symbolic $+C$; specifying a particular constant value is equally valid.